Lord’s Library editors offer a John 5:4 meaning with commentary on why the verse is missing from new Bible versions, for your edification.
When trying to understand the meaning of John 5:4 and see why it’s missing in modern versions, first see the verse: “For an angel went down at a certain season into the pool, and troubled the water: whosoever then first after the troubling of the water stepped in was made whole of whatsoever disease he had.”
This verse provides the supernatural context for why a great multitude of sick people gathered at the pool of Bethesda in Jerusalem. It explains the hope that drove them to wait there—the belief that an angel of the Lord stirred the waters, and that whoever entered first would be healed.
In the King James Bible, this verse is present in full; a part of the inspired record. But in nearly every modern Bible version—ESV, NIV, NASB, CSB—John 5:4 is completely removed, often without so much as a footnote or with a dismissive bracketed note saying that “some manuscripts do not include this verse.” In fact, not only is verse 4 removed, but part of verse 3 is also cut, stripping out the words, “waiting for the moving of the water.”
The result is a nonsensical passage: the reader is told in verse 3 that a multitude of impotent people are lying by the pool, but without verses 3b and 4, there is no explanation why. In verse 7, the impotent man complains that he has no one to help him into the water when it is “troubled”—but in the modern Bibles, the reader has no idea what he’s talking about.
John 5:4 Missing Meaning
The defense for this deletion is an appeal to what some refer to as the “oldest and best manuscripts,” meaning Codex Vaticanus and Codex Sinaiticus—two fourth-century Alexandrian manuscripts that form the foundation of the Nestle-Aland critical text, which nearly all modern versions follow. These two documents omit John 5:4, and because modern textual criticism puts its eggs in the basket of those two manuscripts above the thousands of consistent Byzantine manuscripts.
But the Byzantine tradition—the same manuscript stream that gave us the Textus Receptus and the King James Bible—includes the verse in the overwhelming majority of copies. It was read, believed, and preached by the early Church for centuries. And the belief in angelic intervention at the pool of Bethesda was real enough that Jesus did not rebuke it. He simply asked the man if he wanted to be made whole. So the modern claim that this verse represents an “unverified tradition” not worthy of Scripture is seen by many as heretical.
Removing John 5:4 does more than create narrative confusion. It scrubs the supernatural. It de-emphasizes angelic activity. It erases a moment where God showed mercy and power even before the public ministry of Christ began. And once again, we must ask: Why is it always these kinds of verses? Why are the verses that declare God’s power, judgment, or miracles the ones that get axed? It’s never the genealogies that get removed. It’s always the hard truths and the high wonders. There is a satanic logic to this: dull the Bible, strip the supernatural, sow confusion, and cause the average reader to drift from faith to skepticism. That is exactly what modern versions have accomplished. Ask a Christian today why the crippled man was waiting by the pool, and they’ll likely be confused—because their Bible has omitted the answer. And who benefits from that? Certainly not the Church.
John 5:4 belongs in the Bible. It is preserved in the King James because the KJV translators followed the received and believed text of the Church—the same Scriptures that fueled revivals, conversions, and missionary movements for centuries. It does not defer to corrupt manuscripts that were literally pulled out of the trash (as Sinaiticus was) or locked away in the Vatican. It trusts the God of preservation over the scholars of doubt. If your Bible omits John 5:4, you aren’t holding a cleaner text—you’re holding a gutted one. One that cuts out the moving of the water, the angelic activity, and a glimpse of God’s mercy before the cross.
Stick with the Book that never left it out. Stick with the King James Bible. Because God’s Word doesn’t need to be corrected—it just needs to be believed.
Lord's Library is a Christian resource hub. Our editors use a variety of internet research methods like search engines, audio and video, AI, consultations with ministry leaders in the field, and more. Lord's Library should never be a substitute for reading your Bible daily as the Scriptures are to be our final authority on all matters. Lord's Library participates in affiliate programs. We may make a small commission from products purchased through this resource.
- John 5:4 Meaning: Why is it Missing in Modern Bibles? - June 21, 2025
- What Does the Bible Say About Betrayal? With Key Scriptures - June 19, 2025
- John 7:53-8:11 Meaning: Why is it Missing in Modern Bibles? - June 19, 2025
